Reshoring After COVID-19 Presents Economic Development Opportunities
By Colleen and Jim Walton
Brand Acceleration, Inc.
As we begin to plan for a post-pandemic world, a movement to reshore or attract the manufacture of certain “essential” products has been gaining traction. Economic developers across the nation are aware that landing a new or expanding manufacturer that might create jobs and investment in their community could be a key part of their economic recovery process. It could also provide a much-needed level of industry diversification. There is a lot of speculation about which industries are essential and how to begin the attraction process.
In order to get a better idea what industries will be included in this reshoring effort, Brand Acceleration reached out to site location professionals. The initial question was, “In light of the current COVID-19 crisis, which industries do you believe are most important to bring to the United States?” A follow-up question asked what assets a community would need to have in order to be attractive to these industries. Their recommendations – regarding both industries and assets – are summarized here.
Courtney Dunbar of Burns & McDonnell commented, “I’ve been having discussions surrounding several industrial segments with my colleagues. We anticipate an increase in on-shoring and are working with our industrial clients to determine their best approach in doing so.”
A majority of the site location professionals interviewed stated that medical products will be one of the most highly sought-after industries to be reshored. Here are a few of their stated needs:
- Proximity to medical research institutions
- Significant number of employers in durable goods manufacturing
- Lower costs of labor, real estate, and construction
- Cost advantages associated with a state’s right-to-work status
- Available existing buildings
- Low-cost electricity
- Excellent transportation assets
John H. Boyd, Principal at The Boyd Company, said, “[Pharma] is a client base whose site selection requirements are very demanding. Chief among them are a significant precedent base of the pharma industry in order to provide management/scientific/technical staff that are transferring a high level of career confidence and to ensure the selective recruiting of qualified local new hires at start-up, a highly skilled workforce in fields like biology, chemistry, bioinformatics, genetics, botany, microbiology and other bioscience disciplines, including support fields like government affairs, regulation and compliance.” Desirable community assets include:
- Proximity to research institutions
- Existing pharma and/or animal science companies
- Available existing buildings
- Available building with clean environments or buildings that could be easily converted
- Access to talent with education and experience in life sciences
Electronics, Automation, and Communications Equipment
According to Harry Moser of the Reshoring Initiative®, “We cannot afford to be cut off from supply, e.g. medical devices, but also rare earth minerals, semiconductors, automation equipment, aluminum, etc.” What we need for living and, if necessary, defense.
- Access to rare earth inputs
- This article may be good news for this industry
- Quick access to consumer markets
- Access to talent and education
Food and Beverage
Food is an area of growing concern. With processing plants closing, the fear of food shortages is growing, along with concerns about losing control of food quality and availability. Christopher Lloyd, McGuireWoods Consulting, points out that the US regulatory system still enjoys widespread trust. Other expectations include:
- Food programs in schools
- Plenty of excess available water
- Access to consumer markets
In addition to the items outlined above, several of the site location professionals interviewed mentioned the following as important assets when it comes to a reshoring effort:
- Substantial pool of skilled labor
- Creative incentives for employers making large investments but not necessarily hiring large numbers
- Access to state research and development incentives
Competition will be fierce, but the current situation has shown that there is a demand for these “essential” products. By assessing their assets, economic developers across the nation may find potential opportunities for growth and development in reshoring.
Many thanks to the following professionals who shared their opinions:
John H. Boyd, The Boyd Company, Inc.
Dennis Donovan, Wadley Donovan Gutshaw Consulting
Courtney Dunbar, Burns & McDonnell
Jay Garner, Garner Economics, LLC
Christopher Lloyd, McGuireWoods Consulting
Michael McDermott, Cushman & Wakefield
Harry Moser, Reshoring Initiative®
A research and arts project to document how eastern Ohio has been shaped by changes in the coal industry was awarded a $35,000 grant from the Sustainability Institute at Ohio State. The Ohio Coal Transition: Pathways for Community Resilience is a partnership between The Ohio State University’s School of Environment and Natural Resources, OSU Extension, University Libraries, and the departments of Theatre, Geography and Civil, Environmental, and Geodetic Engineering.read more
Much more than just “drug houses”; State grants to fund commercial building demolition would propel county land banks as key drivers of Ohio’s economic development
In late April 2021, a legislative committee in the Ohio House held its second hearing to consider creating a $100 million grant program, exclusively for county land banks, to fund commercial building demolition. Ohio’s land bank statutes are recognized as a national model, uniquely providing an opt-in for county commissioners to direct tax collections to fund their county land banks’ activities. That revenue model, coupled with allocations from the state’s Hardest Hit Fund (specifically, the sun-setting Neighborhood Initiative Program), allowed land banks to grow in number during the past decade and thrive in addressing so-called nonproductive land in their communities.read more
Archbold, Ohio – Communication, collaboration, and partnerships are all sometimes a difficult ask. The ultimate goal of all three is to produce action that leads to meeting a goal or need. At Paulding High School, the goal was met as five students completed the Northwest State Community College welding course. The offering, consisting of two college level welding courses, came to fruition alongside the OhioMeansJobs-Defiance and Paulding Counties Office, the Paulding County Economic Development Office, Paulding High School, and Northwest State Community College.read more